Comments on Chris Gross: Code Review editor for Eclipse

hey chris, i just want to say thank you for the to...

2011-06-11T17:23:38.031-04:00

hey chris, i just want to say thank you for the tool. it easy, and it work.

Pretty cool, when will the code review editor be a...

2011-05-08T01:26:16.828-04:00

Pretty cool, when will the code review editor be available? Will this be a free plugin for eclipse?

2011-05-05T11:07:45.997-04:00

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

This plugin is available at www.elementriver.com/r...

2011-02-04T08:16:48.080-05:00

This plugin is available at www.elementriver.com/reviewmate

2010-10-21T00:33:52.458-04:00

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

Hi, that's exactly what we are searching for....

2010-07-19T04:45:47.717-04:00

Hi,

that's exactly what we are searching for... when/where can I get it? ;-)

We haven't thought about integration with any ...

2010-01-19T10:02:43.148-05:00

We haven't thought about integration with any other tools as of yet. Right now we're focused on making it a.) have a great UI and b.) be as simple as possible (i.e. just a plugin installation, no server, no other requirements).

Have you thought about ReviewBoard integration?

Simply awesome!! I'm really looking forward to...

2010-01-15T08:07:52.643-05:00

Simply awesome!! I'm really looking forward to see you releasing the stand-alone version. That's exactly what we were looking for for a long time.

Thanks guys.

2010-01-14T17:37:32.872-05:00

Thanks guys.

Well done, looks great!

2010-01-14T16:14:56.017-05:00

Well done, looks great!

Love it! Local xml files that you can put into SCM...

2010-01-14T12:42:46.721-05:00

Love it! Local xml files that you can put into SCM is a great solution. I've looked at/demo'd some web-based tools, but imo much better to be simpler and avoid the server piece and corresponding deployment and complexity.

Yes it will be a pure Eclipse plugin. No server, ...

2010-01-14T08:34:21.304-05:00

Yes it will be a pure Eclipse plugin. No server, no other special requirements.

We don't intend to release it as open source. We will make it commercially available, but likely for a rather low price point.

As for when it will be available, likely within the next 6-12 weeks.

Hi, just fantastic ... it sounds really interesti...

2010-01-14T08:13:46.071-05:00

Hi,

just fantastic ... it sounds really interesting.

is there any more concrete plan than "we plan on pulling it out into an independent product" ?

So will it be

a) a pure Eclipse plugin
b) open-source or free available

and is the timeplan something like "oh we really should do it sometimes" or like "ok - shipping next week" ?

Thanks and cheers

really cool, Chris.

2010-01-13T17:19:04.402-05:00

really cool, Chris.

@Chris. Simple and low-tech. I like it!

2010-01-13T17:04:06.885-05:00

@Chris. Simple and low-tech. I like it!

No central server. Review information is stored i...

2010-01-13T16:56:05.563-05:00

No central server. Review information is stored in an xml file and you simply check it in/out from your source control system.

Looks great! How do reviewer comments get into yo...

2010-01-13T16:32:16.242-05:00

Looks great! How do reviewer comments get into your Eclipse session? Is there a central server that collects and distributes them (and, perhaps, review requests)?

@Peter thx! @David I've seen the proposal and...

2010-01-13T16:24:21.546-05:00

@Peter thx!

@David I've seen the proposal and there appears to be a few screenshots of the tool in the linked powerpoint. From what I can see it doesn't focus on the comment UI like we have done. It it might still be interesting to collaborate - but of course we're a commercial company and don't want to release everything as open source.

Looks really neat. Are you aware of ReviewClipse?...

2010-01-13T16:10:53.210-05:00

Looks really neat. Are you aware of ReviewClipse? They've recently made a project proposal: http://www.eclipse.org/proposals/mylyn-reviews/
I'd be interested to see how this differs from ReviewClipse, and if it makes sense for you to collaborate with them?

This is pretty cool! I like the idea a lot.

2010-01-13T15:47:15.093-05:00

This is pretty cool! I like the idea a lot.